| Year |
Final Score |
Winning Coach |
Location |
| 1973 |
Mishawaka Marian 21, Providence 14 |
Mike Hecklinski |
Providence |
| 1974 |
Garrett 20, North Knox 6 |
David Wiant |
Garrett |
| 1975 |
Lawrenceburg 28, Wes-Del 14 |
Dick Meador |
Lawrenceburg |
| 1976 |
Lafayette Central Catholic 8, Lawrenceburg 6 |
Paul LaRocca |
Lafayette Central Catholic |
| 1977 |
Indianapolis Ritter 15, Tippecanoe Valley 6 |
Duffy Hagist |
Lawrence Central |
| 1978 |
Lawrenceburg 34, Fountain Central 6 |
Dick Meador |
Lawrence Central |
| 1979 |
Tippecanoe Valley 44, Hamilton Southeastern 14 |
Charles Smith |
Lawrence Central |
| 1980 |
Sheridan 27, North Judson 0 |
Larry Wright |
Lawrence Central |
| 1981 |
Hamilton Southeastern 7, Woodlan 6 |
Dave Enright |
Lawrence Central |
| 1982 |
Oak Hill 14, Southridge 7 |
Terry Lichtenberg |
Lawrence Central |
| 1983 |
Fountain Central 12, Churubusco 3 |
Rick Malone |
Lawrence North |
| 1984 |
Sheridan 19, North Judson 10 |
Larry Wright |
Hoosier Dome |
| 1985 |
Eastern Hancock 20, Jimtown 7 |
Bob Copeland |
Hoosier Dome |
| 1986 |
South Putnam 29, North Judson 21 |
Mark Wildman |
Hoosier Dome |
| 1987 |
Sheridan 10, Jimtown 0 |
Larry Wright |
Hoosier Dome |
| 1988 |
Sheridan 59, Bremen 0 |
Larry Wright |
Hoosier Dome |
| 1989 |
Bremen 31, Springs Valley 8 |
John Kucela |
Hoosier Dome |
| 1990 |
South Decatur 44, Southwood 15 |
Ken Wendling |
Hoosier Dome |
| 1991 |
Jimtown 13, Indianapolis Ritter 7 |
Bill Sharpe |
Hoosier Dome |
| 1992 |
Sheridan 6, Indianapolis Ritter 0 |
Larry Wright |
Hoosier Dome |
| 1993 |
North Miami 37, West Washington 16 |
Bob Bridge |
Hoosier Dome |
| 1994 |
North White 34, Sheridan 7 |
Jim Davis |
RCA Dome |
| 1995 |
Carroll (Flora) 26, Tri-West 13 |
John Hendryx |
RCA Dome |
| 1996 |
Tri-West 37, Carroll (Flora) 14 |
Mark Haste |
RCA Dome |
| 1997 |
Pioneer 49, Knightstown 21 |
Mike Johnson |
RCA Dome |
| 1998 |
Sheridan 56, North White 33 |
Larry Wright |
RCA Dome |
| 1999 |
Lafayette Central Catholic 59, Perry Central 7 |
Scott Muncy |
RCA Dome |
| 2000 |
Adams Central 29, Attica 21 |
Rick Minnich |
RCA Dome |
| 2001 |
Southern Wells 30, Perry Central 7 |
Mark Lefebvre |
RCA Dome |
| 2002 |
Southwood 17, South Putnam 14 |
Terry Siddall |
RCA Dome |
| 2003 |
Indianapolis Ritter 28, Seeger 0 |
Jim Bosell |
RCA Dome |
| 2004 |
Seeger 20, Indianapolis Ritter 7 |
Brian Moore |
RCA Dome |
| 2005 |
Sheridan 21, Knightstown 7 |
Larry Wright |
RCA Dome |
| 2006 |
Sheridan 34, Indianapolis Ritter 28, OT |
Larry Wright |
RCA Dome |
| 2007 |
Sheridan 34, Rockville 28 |
Larry Wright |
RCA Dome |
| 2008 |
Indianapolis Ritter 34, Sheridan 27 |
Ty Hunt |
Lucas Oil Stadium |
| 2009 |
Lafayette Central Catholic 52, Fountain Central 0 |
Kevin O'Shea |
Lucas Oil Stadium |
| 2010 |
Lafayette Central Catholic 31, Fountain Central 6 |
Kevin O'Shea |
Lucas Oil Stadium |
